Which To Choose For Fantasmic Package - PassPorter - A Community of Walt Disney World, Disneyland, Disney Cruise Line, and General Travel Forums
PassPorter.com
Award-winning travel guidebooks

   guidebooks   |   news   |   podcasts   |   boards   |   blog   |   worksheets   |   photos   |   articles   |   updates   |   register   |   follow us on


Forums Closed
As of January 1, 2019, we have closed our forums. This is a decision we did not come to lightly, but it is necessary. The software our forums run on is just too out-of-date and it poses a significant security risk. The server software itself must be updated, and it cannot be without removing the forums.

So it is with a heavy heart that we say goodbye to our long-running forums. They came online in 2000 and brought together so many wonderful Disney fans. We had friendships form, careers launch, couples marry, children born ... all because of this amazing community.

Thank you to each of you who were a part of this community. You made it possible.

And a very special thank you to our Guides (moderators), past and present, who kept our forums a happy place to be. You are the glue that held everything together, and we are forever grateful to you. Thank you aliceinwdw, Caldercup, MrsM, WillCAD, Fortissimo, GingerJ, HiddenMickey, CRCrazy, Eeyoresmom, disneyknut, disneydani, Cam22, chezp, WDWfan, Luvsun, KMB733, rescuesk, OhToodles!, Colexis Mom, lfredsbo, HiddenMickey, DrDolphin, DopeyGirl, duck addict, Disneybine, PixieMichele, Sandra Bostwick, Eeyore Tattoo, DyanKJ130, Suzy Q'Disney, LilMarcieMouse, AllisonG, Belle*, Chrissi, Brant, DawnDenise, Crystalloubear, Disneymom9092, FanOfMickey, Goofy4Goofy, GoofyMom, Home4us123, iamgrumpy, ilovedisney247, Jennifer2003, Jenny Pooh, KrisLuvsDisney, Ladyt, Laughaholic88, LauraBelle Hime, Lilianna, LizardCop, Loobyoxlip, lukeandbrooksmom, marisag, michnash, MickeyMAC, OffKilter_Lynn, PamelaK, Poor_Eeyore, ripkensnana, RobDVC, SHEANA1226, Shell of the South, snoozin, Statelady01, Tara O'Hara, tigger22, Tink and Co., Tinkerbelz, WDWJAMBA, wdwlovers, Wendyismyname, whoSEZ, WildforWD, and WvuGrrrl. You made the magic.

We want to personally thank Sara Varney, who coordinated our community for many years (among so many other things she did for us), and Cheryl Pendry, our Message Board Manager who helped train our Guides, and Ginger Jabour, who helped us with the PassPorter-specific forums and Live! Guides. Thank you for your time, energy, and enthusiasm​. You made it all happen.

There are other changes as well.

Why? Well, the world has changed. And change with it, we must. The lyrics to "We Go On" for IllumiNations say it best:

We go on to the joy and through the tears
We go on to discover new frontiers
Moving on with the current of the years.
We go on
Moving forward now as one
Moving on with a spirit born to run
Ever on with each rising sun.
To a new day, we go on.

It's time to move on and move forward.

PassPorter is a small business, and for many years it supported our family. But the world changed, print books took a backseat to the Internet, and for a long time now it has been unable to make ends meet. We've had to find new ways to support our family, which means new careers and less and less time available to devote to our first baby, PassPorter.

But eventually, we must move on and move forward. It is the right thing to do.

So we are retiring this newsletter, as we simply cannot keep up with it. Many thanks to Mouse Fan Travel who supported it all these years, to All Ears and MousePlanet who helped us with news, to our many article contributors, and -- most importantly -- to Sara Varney who edited our newsletter so wonderfully for years and years.

And we are no longer charging for the Live Guides. If you have a subscription, it's yours to keep for the lifetime of the Live Guides at no additional cost. The Live Guides will stay online, barring server issues and technical problems, for all of 2019.

That said, PassPorter is not going away. Most of the resources will remain online for as long as we can support them, and after that we will find ways to make whatever we can available. PassPorter means a great deal to us, and to many of you, and we will do our best to keep it alive in whatever way we can. Our server costs are high, and they'll need to come out of our pockets, so in the future you can expect some changes so we can bring those costs down.

Thank you, thank you, thank you for your amazing support over the years. Without you, there's no way us little guys could have made something like this happen and given the "big guys" a run for their money. PassPorter was consistently the #3 guidebook after the Unofficial and Official guides, which was really unheard of for such a small company to do. We ROCKED it thanks to you and your support and love!

If you miss us, you can still find some of us online. Sara started a new blog at DisneyParkPrincess.com -- I strongly urge you to visit and get on her mailing list. She IS the Disney park princess and knows Disney backward and forward. And I am blogging as well at JenniferMaker.com, which is a little craft blog I started a couple of years ago to make ends meet. You can see and hear me in my craft show at https://www.youtube.com/c/jennifermaker . Many PassPorter readers and fans are on Facebook, in groups they formed like the PassPorter Trip Reports and PassPorter Crafting Challenge (if you join, just let them know you read about it in the newsletter). And some of our most devoted community members started a forum of their own at Pixie Dust Lane and all are invited over.

So we encourage you to stay in touch with us and your fellow community members wherever works best for you!

Best wishes for a wonderful and magical new year!

Go Back   PassPorter - A Community of Walt Disney World, Disneyland, Disney Cruise Line, and General Travel Forums > PassPorter's Walt Disney World Resort (Florida) > Feasting and Snacking: The Eateries at Walt Disney World
Register


Welcome! We're happy you've found the PassPorter Community -- the friendliest place to plan your vacation to Walt Disney World, Disney Cruise Line, Disneyland, and the world in general! You are now viewing the PassPorter Message Board Community as a guest, which gives you limited access. As our guest, feel free to browse our messages by selecting the forum you want to visit from the list below.

To post messages and ask questions, join our FREE community today and you'll get access to tools and resources not available to guests, such as our vacation countown timers, "living" avatars, private messaging system, database searches, downloads, and a special PassPorter discount code. Registration is fast, simple, and completely free. Just click the Join Our Community link.

If you think you've already joined, log in below now. If you don't remember your member name or password, please visit our Member Name and Password Recovery page. You are also welcome to contact us.

View Poll Results: Which would you choose?
Hollywood and Vine 14 51.85%
Mama Melrose 13 48.15%
Voters: 27. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 01-15-2009, 02:15 PM   #1
lissybri
Community Rank: Jetsetter
 
lissybri's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Philadelphia, PA
Posts: 2,882

Post Thanks / Like
Which To Choose For Fantasmic Package

We've been to both Hollywood and Vine (2008) and Mama Melrose (2007). I am having a hard time picking one this year. Which would you take a first timer to?
__________________
[SIGPIC]
Liz
Read MY Trip Reports Here:

Eight is Enough - a July 2014 Trip Report
My Countdown Counting down to: It's been way too long!!
Here we go......
My Previous TripsA few day trips when I was a child, CBR May 1997 (engaged), CBR June 2007 with our 2 boys, Pop Century August 2008 (10th Anniversary), Boardwalk & BLT in August 2011, Wilderness Lodge in June/July 2012
lissybri is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-15-2009, 03:04 PM   #2
RobDVC
Facebook Addict
PassPorter's Club Passholder


What's this?

Community Rank:
Legend Extraordinaire
 
RobDVC's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Philadelphia
Concierge Level: 6
Posts: 39,682

Post Thanks / Like
I love H&V's buffet!
__________________
RobDVC - about me
My Countdown Counting down to: Another BLT visit
..See Ya Real Soon!
My PassPorter Bookshelf <table width=100% height=75 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=0 border=0><tr><td width=86 style='background-image: url(http://www.passporter.com/concierge/ticker/countdown7873-428.png); background-repeat: no-repeat;'><a href='http://www.passporterboards.com/concierge/back-to-the-beach-club-villas-trip428.html' border=0><img src='http://www.passporter.com/forums/club/images/bookshelf/transparent.png' height=75 width=86 border=0></a></td><td align=left style='background-image: url(http://www.passporter.com/forums/club/images/bookshelf/shelf7873.png); background-repeat: no-repeat;'><a href='http://www.passporterboards.com/forums/club/bookshelf.php?member=7873&name=RobDVC' border=0><img src='http://www.passporter.com/forums/club/images/bookshelf/transparent.png' height=75 width=200 border=0></a></td></tr></table>
My Previous TripsMay1991 Treehouse Villas - May1993 POFQ - July1998 CSR - May2002 ASSP - August2004 ASMO - December2005 SSR - August2006 BCV - April2007 POFQ - August2008 BWV - May2009 AKV Kidani - AugSep2010 BLT - Aug2011 BCV - Aug2013 BLT
RobDVC is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-15-2009, 03:05 PM   #3
Momof4gr8boys
Community Rank: Traveler
 
Momof4gr8boys's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Washington
Posts: 356

Post Thanks / Like
I would seriously go with Mama Melrose! We did the H&V Fantasmic! package in early December and I would never, ever go back to that place again. I think we saw our waiter twice the entire night and you would not believe how disgusting the bathrooms were. They were so bad I walked in and then walked right back out and I felt like I needed one of those showers that rid you of all filth and airborne bacteria. And to top it off I was so upset and disgusted about the bathroom I was afraid to eat!
__________________
My Previous TripsDisneyland - December 2000 Disney World - POR - September 2007 Disney World - CSR - December 2008
Momof4gr8boys is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-15-2009, 03:22 PM   #4
disney_duke
Community Rank: Explorer
 
disney_duke's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Wisconsin
Concierge Level: 9
Posts: 11,022

Post Thanks / Like
Having never been to Mama Melrose, I would vote for H&V. We had a great dinner there, lots of yummy food to choose from. Can't go wrong with a buffet. There's usually something for everyone. (mmm, I'm craving some of those yummy sweet potatoes now!) And our server was excellent. She was right ontop of everything we needed before we even had to ask. The selection of desserts was sooo good I'd book the Fantasmic package again there. Plus, if I recall correctly, it's just a tad less expensive than Mama Melrose.
__________________
Tanya
Every click helps feed .6 bowls of food to rescued animals. Give a quick click every day and help animals in shelters! www.theanimalrescuesite.com
My PassPorter Bookshelf
My Previous TripsVisited WDW 4 times while little from 1979 to 1990 ~ Jan. 1998, Doubletree ~ Nov. 1998, Disney Institute ~ Sept. 2000, E. Caribbean Disney Magic ~ July 2001, Courtyard Downtown Disney ~ March 2003, Comfort Inn ~ June 2004, POR ~ Jan. 2006, POFQ ~ May 2007, All Star Vacation home ~ Jan. 2008, POFQ Half Marathon ~ Sept. 2008, SSR ~ Nov. 2009, CBR ~ March 2010, AsMu Princess Half Marathon ~ Sept. 2010, Disneyland Half Marathon ~ Nov. 2010, CSR ~ Jan. 2011 WDW Marathon ~ Oct. 2011 Wine&Dine Half Marathon, POR ~ Jan. 2012 Relay Marathon, POP ~ May 2012 Expedition Everest Challenge, CBR Pirate room ~ Sept. 2012 Sheraton LBV ~ Nov. 2012 Wyndham Bonnet Creek ~ Jan. 2013 Goofy Challenge, POR Royal Room ~ Apr. 2013 POP ~ Sep 2013 DL DDD ~ Jan 2014, marathon volunteer ~ Oct. 2014, ToT 10 miler, ASSports ~ Jan. 2015 Dopey Challenge, Bonnet Creek ~ July 2015, CSR/Marriott ~ November 2015 DL Avengers ~ January 2017 Bonnet Creek ~
disney_duke is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-15-2009, 03:25 PM   #5
Ransom
Community Rank: Traveler
 
Ransom's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Chicagoland
Posts: 466

Post Thanks / Like
I'd go to Mama Melrose over H&V, but I'd try to go for Brown Derby if I could.
__________________
Life is a process of turning time into memories.
My Previous TripsMany trips to Disneyland in the 70s and 80s. Several trips to WDW this millennium, with more scheduled!
Ransom is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-15-2009, 07:18 PM   #6
MBUS
Community Rank: Globetrotter
 
MBUS's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Boston
Concierge Level: 6
Posts: 3,356

Post Thanks / Like
We always have a nice time (and good food) at Mama Melrose.

Beth
__________________
NYC-Canada Cruise Sept 2012
My Countdown Counting down to: Back to Disney World!
My PassPorter Bookshelf
My Previous TripsBWV/Disney Fantasy/BCV April 2013, Disney Magic NYC-Canada (20th Anniversary!) Sept 2012, BLT/BVW/Royal Pacific June 2012, BWV/Disney Dream Jul 2011, Universal/AKL/Disney Wonder Aug/Sept 2010, BWV/BLT Oct 2009, POR May 2009 (DOD), BWV Oct/Nov 2008, AKL Feb 2008, BWV/Caribe Royale Oct 2007, POR Feb 2007, BWV Nov/Dec 2006, Disneyland Paradise Pier Sept/Oct 2005, BWV Oct 2004, BWV Nov 2003, CSR Jan/Feb 2003, BWV Oct 2002, CBR May 2002, CR Oct 2001, Dix Lndgs May 2001, OKW Nov 2000, Dix Lndgs Oct 1999, Poly May 1998, WL Oct 1997, Dixie Landings Oct 1994, Disneyland (offsite) Jan 1994, POFQ/WL/Dis Institute Oct 1992 (honeymoon!), Poly 1991, Poly 1989, CR 1988, offsite 1987, offsite 1986, Poly 1984, Poly 1980 or 81, CR 1976, CR 1973
MBUS is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-15-2009, 08:16 PM   #7
KatMark
Community Rank: Traveler
 
KatMark's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Carol Stream, IL
Posts: 406

Post Thanks / Like
We chose Mama Melrose. You could NOT pay us to ever go to Hollywood & Vine again. Horrible service and even worse food.
__________________


Headed "Home" for a Mini Trip -- 9/18 - 9/22 at CSR
My Previous TripsWDW 82-CR, 84-CR, 87-CR, 89-Poly, 90-Poly, 96-CR, 97-CSR, 98-CSR, 2000-ASS & CSR, 2003-CSR, 2004-Poly, 2006-CSR, 2007-CSR. 2008-CSR, 2009-CSR
KatMark is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-15-2009, 08:57 PM   #8
Cam22
Batman's Gal/Mickey's Pal
PassPorter's Club Passholder


What's this?

PassPorter Guide

Community Rank:
Legend VIP
 
Cam22's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Owensboro, KY USA
Concierge Level: 6
Posts: 95,254

Post Thanks / Like
We have eaten at both and really like both, but Italian food is my favorite so I picked Mama Melroses.
__________________
My PassPorter Bookshelf
My Previous TripsAKL Jambo April/May 2017--SSR/OKW Sept/Oct 2016 --AKL Kidani May 2016 -- Polynesian Village Resort May 2015 -- OKW/Magic December 2014 -- AKL Jambo House October 2014 -- VWL May 2014--SSR October 2013--AKL/Kidani June 2013--CBR October 2012--BWI June 2012--AKV Jambo House/Kidani Village June 2011 -- November 2010 Beach Club -- June 2010 Beach Club -- October 2009 CBR and Gaylord Palms -- June 2009 AKV/Kidani Village -- June 2008 VWL --June 2007 OKW--June 2006 Disney Wonder/SSR -- June 2005 SSR -- June 2004 VWL -- June 2003 AKL -- August 1997 Off Property -- March 1980 Cocoa Beach
Cam22 is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-15-2009, 09:15 PM   #9
WDWJAMBA
 
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Montana
Concierge Level: 6
Posts: 11,499

Post Thanks / Like
Mama's for the killer field green salad and even better steak over red pepper polenta!
__________________
Claudine- PassPorter Co-Guide for Owning the Magic: Disney Vacation Club

Scarfing down Chocolate Extinction at T-Rex
My Countdown Counting down to: OKW and Cruising to Aruba
Enjoying another Florida vacation
My PassPorter Bookshelf <table width=100% height=75 border=0><tr><td style='background-image: url(http://www.passporter.com/forums/club/images/bookshelf/shelf7382.png); background-repeat: no-repeat;'><a href='http://www.passporterboards.com/concierge/bookshelf.php?member=7382&name=WDWJAMBA' border=0><img src='http://www.passporter.com/forums/club/images/bookshelf/transparent.png' height=75 width=100% border=0></a></td></tr></table>
My Previous TripsJune 2012 Disney Dream and BWV;June 2011 WL and Vero Beach; August 2010 AKLV;April 2010 Disneyland; August 2009 AKLV; April 2009 Disneyland; June 2008 AKLV; December 2007 SSR; June 2007 BCV; June 2006 OKW; June 2005 WL
WDWJAMBA is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-16-2009, 01:29 AM   #10
chezp
PassPorter Message Board Manager
PassPorter Guide Author

Community Rank:
Legend VIP
 
chezp's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Maidstone, Kent, UK
Concierge Level: 3
Posts: 190,285

Post Thanks / Like
We've had good meals at both. I think it depends on the age of those in the party. If you have youngsters, then the Hollywood and Vine. Otherwise, Mama Melrose's.
__________________

Relaxing on board the Magic. The trip report for our back-to-back cruises on the Disney Magic has started!
My Countdown Counting down to: 2019
Happy New Year!
My PassPorter Bookshelf
My Previous Trips21 trips to WDW, 6 to Disneyland in California, 9 to Disneyland Paris, 1 to Hong Kong Disneyland, 1 to Tokyo Disney, 1 to Aulani, 1 to Hilton Head, 2 to Vero Beach and 13 Disney cruises on the Magic, Wonder, Dream and Fantasy
chezp is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-16-2009, 08:38 AM   #11
wendybell
Community Rank: Jetsetter
 
wendybell's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Michigan
Posts: 2,081

Post Thanks / Like
I voted for H&V. We haven't been there since 2006 and it was good then...i see some negitive posts from more recent visits though. We did the Fantasmic! dinner package at Mama Melrose in 2007 and were very disappointed in both the food and service. I think each place has it's pros and cons. Good luck deciding.
__________________
My PassPorter Bookshelf
My Previous TripsMarch 2005 at CBR, May 2006 at POFQ, May 2007 at POFQ, April/May 2008 at Wilderness Lodge!!! October 2010 at POR
wendybell is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-16-2009, 08:47 AM   #12
Griffin
Community Rank: Explorer
 
Griffin's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: New England
Posts: 8,155

Post Thanks / Like
I went for H&V though i've never been to either...But have wanted to try HV!
__________________
My Previous TripsBeen going to WDW since 2000
Griffin is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-16-2009, 05:34 PM   #13
mousestruck
Community Rank: Navigator
 
mousestruck's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: New Jersey
Posts: 6,470

Post Thanks / Like
I like both! That being said, they both offer very different experiences: H&W is much louder and a bit more child-friendly, and Mama Melrose is more relaxing. I think I'd choose Mama Melrose. Good luck with your decision!
__________________
Aimee
My PassPorter Bookshelf
mousestruck is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-18-2009, 08:58 AM   #14
susan
Community Rank: Traveler
 
susan's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2001
Posts: 461

Post Thanks / Like
We always have a good meal at Mama Melrose's ! We are not(ok, I am not, my boys are!!! ) big buffet lovers. We have eaten at Mama's with the package and without. With the Fantasmic Package, there is so much food! You definitely won't go hungry!!!
__________________
Susan
My Previous TripsToo many to count! 13 trips in 15 years! Our favorites: BWI Thanksgiving 2001, YC New Years Eve 2005,2006, BWI New Years Eve 2007, BC 2008, YC 2009,Dolphin NYears 2012, Swan NYears 2013
susan is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-18-2009, 04:01 PM   #15
lukeandbrookesmom
Banned
Community Rank: Legend
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Florida
Posts: 21,767

Post Thanks / Like
Quote:
Originally Posted by chezp View Post
We've had good meals at both. I think it depends on the age of those in the party. If you have youngsters, then the Hollywood and Vine. Otherwise, Mama Melrose's.
lukeandbrookesmom is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Reply




Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump














Please login or register to hide these ads -- it's free and easy!

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:47 PM.

-->

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Feedback Buttons provided by Advanced Post Thanks / Like v3.4.0 Patch Level 1 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
(c) 1998-2017 PassPorter Travel Press/MediaMarx, Inc.
Celebrating 19 Years of Making Dreams Come True
Ad Management plugin by RedTyger