Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival Cruise Line - PassPorter - A Community of Walt Disney World, Disneyland, Disney Cruise Line, and General Travel Forums
PassPorter.com
Award-winning travel guidebooks

   guidebooks   |   news   |   podcasts   |   boards   |   blog   |   worksheets   |   photos   |   articles   |   updates   |   register   |   follow us on


Forums Closed
As of January 1, 2019, we have closed our forums. This is a decision we did not come to lightly, but it is necessary. The software our forums run on is just too out-of-date and it poses a significant security risk. The server software itself must be updated, and it cannot be without removing the forums.

So it is with a heavy heart that we say goodbye to our long-running forums. They came online in 2000 and brought together so many wonderful Disney fans. We had friendships form, careers launch, couples marry, children born ... all because of this amazing community.

Thank you to each of you who were a part of this community. You made it possible.

And a very special thank you to our Guides (moderators), past and present, who kept our forums a happy place to be. You are the glue that held everything together, and we are forever grateful to you. Thank you aliceinwdw, Caldercup, MrsM, WillCAD, Fortissimo, GingerJ, HiddenMickey, CRCrazy, Eeyoresmom, disneyknut, disneydani, Cam22, chezp, WDWfan, Luvsun, KMB733, rescuesk, OhToodles!, Colexis Mom, lfredsbo, HiddenMickey, DrDolphin, DopeyGirl, duck addict, Disneybine, PixieMichele, Sandra Bostwick, Eeyore Tattoo, DyanKJ130, Suzy Q'Disney, LilMarcieMouse, AllisonG, Belle*, Chrissi, Brant, DawnDenise, Crystalloubear, Disneymom9092, FanOfMickey, Goofy4Goofy, GoofyMom, Home4us123, iamgrumpy, ilovedisney247, Jennifer2003, Jenny Pooh, KrisLuvsDisney, Ladyt, Laughaholic88, LauraBelle Hime, Lilianna, LizardCop, Loobyoxlip, lukeandbrooksmom, marisag, michnash, MickeyMAC, OffKilter_Lynn, PamelaK, Poor_Eeyore, ripkensnana, RobDVC, SHEANA1226, Shell of the South, snoozin, Statelady01, Tara O'Hara, tigger22, Tink and Co., Tinkerbelz, WDWJAMBA, wdwlovers, Wendyismyname, whoSEZ, WildforWD, and WvuGrrrl. You made the magic.

We want to personally thank Sara Varney, who coordinated our community for many years (among so many other things she did for us), and Cheryl Pendry, our Message Board Manager who helped train our Guides, and Ginger Jabour, who helped us with the PassPorter-specific forums and Live! Guides. Thank you for your time, energy, and enthusiasm​. You made it all happen.

There are other changes as well.

Why? Well, the world has changed. And change with it, we must. The lyrics to "We Go On" for IllumiNations say it best:

We go on to the joy and through the tears
We go on to discover new frontiers
Moving on with the current of the years.
We go on
Moving forward now as one
Moving on with a spirit born to run
Ever on with each rising sun.
To a new day, we go on.

It's time to move on and move forward.

PassPorter is a small business, and for many years it supported our family. But the world changed, print books took a backseat to the Internet, and for a long time now it has been unable to make ends meet. We've had to find new ways to support our family, which means new careers and less and less time available to devote to our first baby, PassPorter.

But eventually, we must move on and move forward. It is the right thing to do.

So we are retiring this newsletter, as we simply cannot keep up with it. Many thanks to Mouse Fan Travel who supported it all these years, to All Ears and MousePlanet who helped us with news, to our many article contributors, and -- most importantly -- to Sara Varney who edited our newsletter so wonderfully for years and years.

And we are no longer charging for the Live Guides. If you have a subscription, it's yours to keep for the lifetime of the Live Guides at no additional cost. The Live Guides will stay online, barring server issues and technical problems, for all of 2019.

That said, PassPorter is not going away. Most of the resources will remain online for as long as we can support them, and after that we will find ways to make whatever we can available. PassPorter means a great deal to us, and to many of you, and we will do our best to keep it alive in whatever way we can. Our server costs are high, and they'll need to come out of our pockets, so in the future you can expect some changes so we can bring those costs down.

Thank you, thank you, thank you for your amazing support over the years. Without you, there's no way us little guys could have made something like this happen and given the "big guys" a run for their money. PassPorter was consistently the #3 guidebook after the Unofficial and Official guides, which was really unheard of for such a small company to do. We ROCKED it thanks to you and your support and love!

If you miss us, you can still find some of us online. Sara started a new blog at DisneyParkPrincess.com -- I strongly urge you to visit and get on her mailing list. She IS the Disney park princess and knows Disney backward and forward. And I am blogging as well at JenniferMaker.com, which is a little craft blog I started a couple of years ago to make ends meet. You can see and hear me in my craft show at https://www.youtube.com/c/jennifermaker . Many PassPorter readers and fans are on Facebook, in groups they formed like the PassPorter Trip Reports and PassPorter Crafting Challenge (if you join, just let them know you read about it in the newsletter). And some of our most devoted community members started a forum of their own at Pixie Dust Lane and all are invited over.

So we encourage you to stay in touch with us and your fellow community members wherever works best for you!

Best wishes for a wonderful and magical new year!

Go Back   PassPorter - A Community of Walt Disney World, Disneyland, Disney Cruise Line, and General Travel Forums > PassPorter Universe: General Trip Planning and Discussion > Globetrotting: General Travel Planning
Register


Welcome! We're happy you've found the PassPorter Community -- the friendliest place to plan your vacation to Walt Disney World, Disney Cruise Line, Disneyland, and the world in general! You are now viewing the PassPorter Message Board Community as a guest, which gives you limited access. As our guest, feel free to browse our messages by selecting the forum you want to visit from the list below.

To post messages and ask questions, join our FREE community today and you'll get access to tools and resources not available to guests, such as our vacation countown timers, "living" avatars, private messaging system, database searches, downloads, and a special PassPorter discount code. Registration is fast, simple, and completely free. Just click the Join Our Community link.

If you think you've already joined, log in below now. If you don't remember your member name or password, please visit our Member Name and Password Recovery page. You are also welcome to contact us.

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 01-24-2010, 02:43 PM   #1
BelmontBelle
Community Rank: Scout
 
BelmontBelle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Grand Blanc, MI
Concierge Level: 4
Posts: 4,238

Post Thanks / Like
Royal Caribbean vs. Carnival Cruise Line

We are planning on a 5-6 day cruise this summer, we are not going to do a Disney Cruise. I priced one, along with Royal Caribbean and Carnival and I can't justify the huge price difference. If my kids were still little it would be one thing, but I think that as teens they will have as much fun on one of the other ships. Can anyone advise on which of those two would be the preference? The Carnival a that we are looking at is a newer ship (The Freedom) with lots of bells and whistles. The RCCL ship (Grandeur of the Seas) is a bit smaller and older with not so many extras but it gets great reviews and we are liking the ports slightly better. Any thoughts or advice would be appreciated! We've never cruised before if it makes any difference. Thanks!
__________________


Lisa - Travel Consultant affiliated with MouseEarVacations and CruisingCo.com
https://www.facebook.com/LisaScrimge..._type=bookmark
My PassPorter Bookshelf
My Previous Trips2017 CSR, 2016 GFR and POFQ, 2015 Disneyland Hotel, Poly, DCL Disney Magic and Dolphin, 2014 Grand Californian and Dolphin, 2013 Pop, 2012 Pop, 2011 Pop, 2010 Offsite, 2008 Pop, Swan & WL, 2007 POFQ, 2004 WL, 2002 WL, 2001 WL, 2000 CBR, 1999 CBR.
BelmontBelle is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-25-2010, 09:53 AM   #2
lukeandbrookesmom
Banned
Community Rank: Legend
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Florida
Posts: 21,767

Post Thanks / Like
I prefer RCCL over Carnival simply because I think their service is far better. It's our favorite cruise line after Disney.
lukeandbrookesmom is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-25-2010, 10:18 AM   #3
jimmymac
Community Rank:
Legend Extraordinaire
 
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: New York, NY
Posts: 35,829

Post Thanks / Like
Carnival attracts a younger crowd. We've done 3 Royal Caribbean Alaska cruises and never had a single complaint. Fabulous food, service, everything
__________________
Jim
My Countdown Counting down to:
My Previous Trips2015 BC, 2014 BC, 2014 BWI, 2013 BC, 2013 GF, 2012 BC, 2012 OKW, 2012 BWI, 2011 BWI, 2011 BC, 2010 BC, 2010 CSR, 2010 Kidani, 2009 GCV, 2009 BC, 2008 BWV, 2008 Grand Californian, 2008 BC, 2007 BWI, 2007 POFQ, 2007 Grand Californian, 2006 BC, 2006 POR, 2006 WL, 2005 BC, 2005 BWI, 2005 CBR, 2004 CR, 2004 GF, 2004 POFQ 2004 Poly, 2003 Poly, 2003 CSR, 2003 POR, 2002 AKL, 2002 GF, 2001 AKL, 2001 Poly, 2000 CBR, 1999 CBR, 1998 ASMo, 1997 ASMSp, 1996 ASMo, 1995 ASSp, 1991 Wyndham, 1989 off site, 1985 Off Site
jimmymac is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-25-2010, 10:52 AM   #4
Angileyze1
Community Rank: Globetrotter
 
Angileyze1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Milledgeville, Georgia
Concierge Level: 8
Posts: 3,054

Post Thanks / Like
I'm doing Carnival Freedom May2. Its a huge newer ship and I managed a balcony stateroom. I can't wait!
__________________
My Countdown Counting down to: Grandson's firstDisney trip!
Enjoying the Mouse!
My PassPorter Bookshelf
My Previous Trips1977 Ft Wilderness, 1984 Off Site WDW , Nov 2009 CBR/WL split stay, Sept 2010 POR, Jan 2012 CBR, Dec 2012 OKW, Oct 2014 POP.
Angileyze1 is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-27-2010, 06:51 PM   #5
Andrew Oldbury
Community Rank: Day-Tripper
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 5

Post Thanks / Like
Smile andrew

Hi, after a long think about our last trip away we decided to do both a 4 day disney wonder and a 7 day rcc freedom of the seas trip. Disney has the edge on service but wow the rcc is huge. Ice skating,rock climbing,Flowrider(surfing was great),two good size pools to swim in and lots more. The food was good and varied the windjammer cafe for evening was super, relaxed and quiet with all of the food offered in the main dinnig room so you didn't miss out. A little loud at times and a lot more people than on the wonder but still enjoyed it greatly.
The balcony cabins are a good size 3 of us with a good size balcony and if you can get rooms next door to each other you can (in most cases) open the balcony devider to make a huge balcony to share we did and it was great, again disney has the edge on service and the disney was of staff etc but as you said the price is well a little high. Hope this is some use to you
Andrew Oldbury is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 01-28-2010, 06:25 AM   #6
BelmontBelle
Community Rank: Scout
 
BelmontBelle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Grand Blanc, MI
Concierge Level: 4
Posts: 4,238

Post Thanks / Like
Thanks to all for the advice! We decided on Royal Caribbean. Everyone seems to recommend them over Carnival, plus the ports and the dates worked out better for us. If we like cruising maybe we'll do a Disney Cruise when we can book early for better savings.
__________________


Lisa - Travel Consultant affiliated with MouseEarVacations and CruisingCo.com
https://www.facebook.com/LisaScrimge..._type=bookmark
My PassPorter Bookshelf
My Previous Trips2017 CSR, 2016 GFR and POFQ, 2015 Disneyland Hotel, Poly, DCL Disney Magic and Dolphin, 2014 Grand Californian and Dolphin, 2013 Pop, 2012 Pop, 2011 Pop, 2010 Offsite, 2008 Pop, Swan & WL, 2007 POFQ, 2004 WL, 2002 WL, 2001 WL, 2000 CBR, 1999 CBR.
BelmontBelle is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 05-16-2010, 11:29 AM   #7
strtrek
Community Rank: Wayfarer
 
strtrek's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Sydney, Australia.....14914 miles from WDW
Concierge Level: 3
Posts: 155

Post Thanks / Like
hey

we too are doing a 7 night RCL/ freedom of the seas and a 4 night Disney cruise in october....both are costing the same!

i am looking forward to a few more adult activities on RCL, although we love the disney service

we love cruising.....
__________________




DVC Member: : Bay Lake Tower, Vero Beach

Next trip : BLT, BWV, Dream...Sept 2014
My Countdown Counting down to: Our 24th Anniversary trip...and first time on the Disney Dream
We are partying with the Mouse....happiest place ever.
My PassPorter Bookshelf
My Previous TripsWDW 03,06,08,09,10,11,12,13 ...DL 13 ....DCL 09,11..Aulani 12
strtrek is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 05-17-2010, 11:16 AM   #8
Straitlover
Community Rank: Globetrotter
 
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: North Carolina
Posts: 3,958

Post Thanks / Like
Look in the Globetrotter trip report section. There is a PP'er doing a trip report right now from her Carnival Freedom trip.
__________________
Lisa
Straitlover is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 05-23-2010, 04:44 PM   #9
Young Gang mom
Community Rank: Wayfarer
 
Young Gang mom's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: California
Posts: 121

Post Thanks / Like
We did RCCL on the Freedom of the Seas last year and it totally rocked. Having been on Carnival before, I will never go back. RCCL was far superior!
__________________
Young Gang Mom

My Previous TripsWDW Feb. 2012, DLP Oct. 2010, WDW Sept. 2009, DL July 2009, WDW Oct. 2008, DLR Oct. 2006, DLR Oct. 2005, DLR Feb. 1999, DLR July 1992, DLR March 1985, DLR April 1978
Young Gang mom is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 05-24-2010, 08:12 AM   #10
Angileyze1
Community Rank: Globetrotter
 
Angileyze1's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Milledgeville, Georgia
Concierge Level: 8
Posts: 3,054

Post Thanks / Like
Funny, I feel the same about the Carnivasl line. I have never done Royal Carribbean but a family member has and confirmed what we experienced. Carnival is called the FUN SHIPS for a reason. We did the Freedom May 2nd and have no desire to try anything else. We loved it and I am already planning my next Carnival trip for next year. And I don't believe that about the OLDER crowd. My mom is 63 and I am almost 40 and we fell in love with it along with all the 40-60 somethings on our cruise!! I didn't do RC initially because I heard it was more "Stuffy" and people more inclined to be more dressy, ect. I want to feel like I can relax in whatever I want to wear and be dressed down and not stuffy. I want the FUN SHIPS!!!
__________________
My Countdown Counting down to: Grandson's firstDisney trip!
Enjoying the Mouse!
My PassPorter Bookshelf
My Previous Trips1977 Ft Wilderness, 1984 Off Site WDW , Nov 2009 CBR/WL split stay, Sept 2010 POR, Jan 2012 CBR, Dec 2012 OKW, Oct 2014 POP.
Angileyze1 is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 06-22-2010, 10:55 AM   #11
Principessa_di_Fata
Community Rank: Navigator
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: TN
Posts: 6,206

Post Thanks / Like
I know you already made your choice, but I'm weighing in anyway - just for anyone else who may have to decide some day.

I've been on multiple cruise lines multiple times. And I have to be honest, there's not much of a difference to me. Royal Caribbean was fine. Food was good, atmosphere was a little quieter than Carnival, but it was a lovely ship, and the food was great! Carnival was a fantastic cruise. They had all the bells and whistles, and there's a reason they call it the fun ships! They really are fun! I had heard TERRIBLE reviews of Carnival before taking this cruise, so I was nervous, but I actually had a great time. The food was out of this world, the service was spectacular and the ship was so large it never felt crowded.

I've also been on Sun Line, Dolphin and Celebrity. Celebrity is an older crowd, but I still really enjoyed it. It was a far more relaxing cruise for me, and I'd definitely go again.

I think you can't go wrong on any of them, honestly. I choose by ports, never by cruise company or ship, simply because the service (to me) is all the same, the food is great on all of them (maybe I'm just not picky, I don't know, but I've never had a bad meal on any cruise ship) and the amenities are more or less comparable. One ship has a rock wall, one has a water slide, one has mini golf... etc etc... there's always something to do, no matter what ship you're on.

Enjoy your cruise - you're going to have a blast! I LOVE cruising!
__________________
Melanie
Come read my current trip report: http://www.passporterboards.com/foru...ml#post4508836

http://www.passporterboards.com/forums/signaturepics/sigpic13079_16.gif
My Countdown Counting down to: My 40th Birthday Celebration
Cruisin'!!!
My Previous TripsMay 2016 - RCCL Baltic Cruise * Dec 2015 - Carnival Dream Caribbean Cruise (My 40th) * Mar 2015 - EPCOT Day * Nov 2014 - Carnival Elation Caribbean Cruise (Mom's 75th) * Feb 2014 - CBR / Disney Dream Bahamas Cruise (Meri's 8th) * June 2013 - Disneyland Paris * May 2013 - Disney Magic Transatlantic Cruise * Oct 2012 - Disneyland * Sept 2012 - Port Orleans Riverside (Royal Room) * Feb 2012 - Boardwalk Villas / Animal Kingdom Villas (Kidani Village) (Crissy's Bachelorette) * Oct 2011 - Port Orleans Riverside / Bonnet Creek * Feb 2011 - Caribbean Beach Resort (Pirate Room) / Animal Kingdom Lodge (Meri's 5th) * Nov 2009 - Port Orleans French Quarter (Mom's 70th) * Feb 2009 - Coronado Springs (Meri's 3rd) * Feb 2008 - Port Orleans Riverside (Meri's 2nd) * Sept 2006 - Boardwalk Inn * Prior to 2006 - Too many visits to count...
Principessa_di_Fata is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 07-09-2010, 09:03 AM   #12
BelmontBelle
Community Rank: Scout
 
BelmontBelle's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Grand Blanc, MI
Concierge Level: 4
Posts: 4,238

Post Thanks / Like
Quote:
Originally Posted by Principessa_di_Fata View Post
I know you already made your choice, but I'm weighing in anyway - just for anyone else who may have to decide some day.

I've been on multiple cruise lines multiple times. And I have to be honest, there's not much of a difference to me. Royal Caribbean was fine. Food was good, atmosphere was a little quieter than Carnival, but it was a lovely ship, and the food was great! Carnival was a fantastic cruise. They had all the bells and whistles, and there's a reason they call it the fun ships! They really are fun! I had heard TERRIBLE reviews of Carnival before taking this cruise, so I was nervous, but I actually had a great time. The food was out of this world, the service was spectacular and the ship was so large it never felt crowded.

I've also been on Sun Line, Dolphin and Celebrity. Celebrity is an older crowd, but I still really enjoyed it. It was a far more relaxing cruise for me, and I'd definitely go again.

I think you can't go wrong on any of them, honestly. I choose by ports, never by cruise company or ship, simply because the service (to me) is all the same, the food is great on all of them (maybe I'm just not picky, I don't know, but I've never had a bad meal on any cruise ship) and the amenities are more or less comparable. One ship has a rock wall, one has a water slide, one has mini golf... etc etc... there's always something to do, no matter what ship you're on.

Enjoy your cruise - you're going to have a blast! I LOVE cruising!
This is great advice for anyone choosing a cruise. Ultimately we did choose our cruise based on the ports vs. the cruiseline. A week from tomorrow we'll be setting sail...can't wait!!
__________________


Lisa - Travel Consultant affiliated with MouseEarVacations and CruisingCo.com
https://www.facebook.com/LisaScrimge..._type=bookmark
My PassPorter Bookshelf
My Previous Trips2017 CSR, 2016 GFR and POFQ, 2015 Disneyland Hotel, Poly, DCL Disney Magic and Dolphin, 2014 Grand Californian and Dolphin, 2013 Pop, 2012 Pop, 2011 Pop, 2010 Offsite, 2008 Pop, Swan & WL, 2007 POFQ, 2004 WL, 2002 WL, 2001 WL, 2000 CBR, 1999 CBR.
BelmontBelle is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Old 07-09-2010, 12:18 PM   #13
4Disney2
Community Rank: Trekker
 
4Disney2's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: NY (Heart at Disney)
Posts: 1,869

Post Thanks / Like
This is what I have read:

Carnival-Happy ship, more of a party ship, less conservative type

Royal Caribeean- Goes on the same line as Disney, more conservative, up a notch.
still you can relax, and have fun.


for what is worth, depending of what you would like on your cruise.
__________________

Teresa



Link To My Disney Scrapbook Gallery
http://www.mousescrappers.com/photos...scrap-princess
My PassPorter Bookshelf
My Previous Trips~~WDW 1999 Disney Love started ~~WDW 2000 ~~WDW 2001 ~~WDW 2002 Annual Pass holder ~~Disney Cruise Line 2002 ~~WDW 2004 ~~Disneyland 2004 ~~WDW 2006 ~~WDW 2007 ~~WDW & Disney Cruise Line 2008 Anniversary trip! ~~2009 Disneyland Grand Californian ~~2010 January trip to Bay Lake Tower/Kidani Village ~~2010 Disneyland Food & Wine Festival ~~2010 Disneyworld Summer 2010-Beach Club Villas ~~2015 Disney Cruise January 15-24

Last edited by 4Disney2; 07-09-2010 at 12:21 PM..
4Disney2 is offline  
 
Reply With Quote
Reply




Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump














Please login or register to hide these ads -- it's free and easy!

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:25 PM.

-->

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Feedback Buttons provided by Advanced Post Thanks / Like v3.4.0 Patch Level 1 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2024 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
(c) 1998-2017 PassPorter Travel Press/MediaMarx, Inc.
Celebrating 19 Years of Making Dreams Come True
Ad Management plugin by RedTyger